Gotta Love/Hate Regex

Wed, Aug 5, 2020 3-minute read

I remember once calling regular expressions “absolute magic”. I do think it is powerful, but it kind of gets messy and unreadable when it gets bigger. In fact, one of those was the reason I wrote this post. It was in the NLTK book I am currently reading, and it was a little more complex than what I usually use in my code. So, here I am rambling about regex and trying to explain the one I studied today as an example.

The goal

That regex was supposed to to be used as a sort of word tokenizer on this example string:

"'When I'M a Duchess,' she said to herself, (not in a very hopeful tone
though), 'I won't have any pepper in my kitchen AT ALL. Soup does very well
without--Maybe it's always pepper that makes people hot-tempered,'..."

There is more to words than being a set of alphanumeric characters separated by whitespace. There is punctuation in the middle: hyphens, parentheses, full stops, etc., but not every punctuation symbol actually separates two words. You can see compound words (e.g. “hot-tempered”) and punctuation without whitespace like the double-hyphen.

The solution

"\w+(?:[-']\w+)*|'|[-.(]+|\S\w*"

I never wrote a regex this long before. So, looking at it, my brain’s first response was “gobbledygook!” To be fair, though, this is relatively simple in the grand scheme of things: they can get really big. (See for yourself…)

Breaking it down

Just like any programming problem, this one is better solved by breaking it down. I will split it by the | because it means “or”, so the whole regex represent multiple choices, and we are trying to match any of them.

Part 1: \w+(?:[-']\w+)*

  • The first part is \w+ which searches for a word (i.e. one or more alphanumeric characters and/or underscores).
  • The pattern (?:___) is for grouping a smaller regex. But what is the smaller regex’s job, and why is it grouped?
  • The smaller regex is [-']\w+ which matches a hyphen or an apostrophe, and either is followed by a word.
  • The grouping is because this whole wrapped regex is followed by a * which means zero or more occurrences.

So this part can be thought of as the main pattern. It covers most of the desired tokens including compound words that are separated with a hyphen (e.g. “hot-tempered”) as well as those with apostrophes (e.g. “I’M”).

Part 2: '

The string of interest had quotes written between literal single quotes. So, we needed our pattern to cover those by, well… using a single quote.

Part 3: [-.(]+

  • The square brackets [] with a set of characters inside of it means that any of those characters should be matched.
  • Here it is followed by a + to indicate that one or more of those characters should be matched.

This part captures punctuation marks like parentheses, full stops, ellipses, and the double hyphen.

Part 4: \S\w*

The last part cleans up with some final touches. It searches for a non-whitespace character followed by 0 or more alphanumeric characters. Here it picks up two tokens that wouldn’t be split otherwise: a comma and a closing parenthesis.


That’s it! Although it is not the most complicated thing in the world, I still it proves the point I said at the beginning: regex can be messy but still really powerful!